Tax Tips & Pits – Courts don’t joke around when it comes to taxes

"So how does a tax preparer spend his or her free time? Reading court rulings, of course."

So how does a tax preparer spend his or her free time? Reading court rulings, of course.

April Fool’s Day aside, no joke, reading court rulings can be entertaining.

That being said, in no way am I downplaying the significance and seriousness of anyone’s health and medical issues they may be enduring, but here is a legal challenge that might make you smile … and then say … if only.

To set the stage, and keeping things simple, for medical services that require travel out of one’s local area, Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) permits travel costs as an allowable medical expense.

The needed medical service must not be available locally as defined by having to travel more than 40 kilometers to another location to receive that medical service.

In a 2015 court case that worked its way to the Federal level, the claiming of travel out of the local area for a necessary medical service was put to the test.

A taxpayer with an undisputed diagnosed debilitating medical condition that had led to the replacement of joints with prosthetic devices was seeking warmer conditions to alleviate the personal suffering created by the prosthetics because of Canada’s cold winter climate.

To provide the relief needed for this medical condition, the taxpayer traveled to Thailand and Indonesia and claimed the travel cost as medically necessary expenses on the T1 personal tax return.

The claim was denied by CRA.

The tax payer appealed to the Tax Court of Canada where the claim was deemed allowable and reinstated by that Court.

CRA then appealed the Tax Court’s decision to the Federal Court of Appeal where that Court ruled in favour of CRA stating that a more favourable climate cannot be defined as a “medical service”.

The taxpayer’s medical claim for travel expenses was denied.

I’m not passing judgement on the Appeal Court’s decision, but given the annual migration of Canadian snowbirds, it’s interesting to ponder about the number of new medical claims that may have resulted if the Court had sided with the taxpayer and allowed the travel claim to a warmer climate.

This legal challenge reminds me of a court case a few years back that eventually led to the denial of a new hot tub purchase as a medical expense.

Ron Clarke has his MBA and is a business owner in Trail, providing accounting and tax services. Email him at ron.clarke@JBSbiz.ca. To read previous Tax Tips & Pits columns visit www.JBSbiz.net.

Just Posted

Extensive road repair nears completion in Fruitvale

The scope of work includes new water and sewer service connections as well as road resurfacing

Columbia Basin Trust announces grant for technology upgrades

The deadline for organizations to apply is Dec. 17

Christmas blooms in downtown Trail

The Artisan Craft Co-op recently celebrated its 30th anniversary in downtown Trail

Community invited to check out mining trade show in Trail

Trade show free and open public on Wednesday and Thursday in the Trail Memorial Centre

Grand Forks to receive business recovery funds post-flood

The community will receive two Rural Dividends grants for a total of $655,000.

VIDEO: Two officers of B.C. Legislature escorted out amid investigation

Clerk of the House Craig James, Sergeant-at-arms Gary Lenz were placed on administrative leave

Shirtless stranger loomed over couch and started stabbing, bloody B.C. murder trial hears

Colin John pleads not guilty as trial opens in 2016 Chemainus murder case

Late 2019 too long to wait for ridesharing: B.C. Conservatives

“While the rest of the world is embracing this transportation revolution, B.C. is only now staggering slowly toward legislation on a business model that’s been mainstreamed for over a decade in other jurisdictions.”

Police aim to prevent retaliation after Hells Angel found dead under B.C. bridge

IHIT confirms Chad Wilson, 43, was the victim of a ‘targeted’ homicide

ICBC warns shoppers of the high-accident season at mall parking lots

Over 150,000 accidents happened during the holiday season last year

No deal in sight: Canada Post warns of delivery delays into January

Union holds fifth week of rotating strikes as both sides remain apart on contract negotiations

COLUMN: Higher interest rates will slow B.C. economy after ‘unusually robust’ show

Jock Finlayson is executive vice president and chief policy officer of the Business Council of BC

Jason Aldean, Old Dominion to headline Merritt’s Rockin’ River concerts next summer

Four-day music festival at Coldwater River from Aug. 1 to 4

Police looking into two more incidents at private Toronto all-boys’ school

Police and the school have said two of the prior incidents involved an alleged sexual assault

Most Read